Cluster gravitational redshifts: uncertainties and survey requirements

Authors: Eleni Tsaprazi, Giorgio F. Lesci, Federico Marulli, Alan F. Heavens, Enrico Maraboli Date: 2026-03-26 Paper ID: arxiv:2603.25339

Summary

This work develops an end-to-end forecasting pipeline to rigorously assess how observational and theoretical uncertainties impact the precision of constraining modified gravity ($\alpha_\mathrm{MG}$) using the gravitational redshift effect in galaxy clusters. The methodology involves generating synthetic halo catalogs using a Halo Occupation Distribution (HOD) model, simulating survey selections, and parameterizing deviations from General Relativity via a linear rescaling of the gravitational potential. Key findings indicate that velocity dispersion sets a precision floor for redshift uncertainty, and that accurate cluster center determination is paramount to avoid misinterpreting systematic errors as new physics in upcoming high-S/N surveys. Ultimately, the study suggests that high-precision spectroscopic surveys are the most effective path for leveraging gravitational redshifts as a competitive probe of modified gravity.

Key Contributions

• Developed an end-to-end forecasting pipeline to quantify the impact of observational and theoretical uncertainties on constraining modified gravity ($\alpha_\mathrm{MG}$) using cluster gravitational redshifts.
• Determined that the intracluster velocity dispersion imposes an effective floor, where redshift precision beyond $\sigma_z\sim 10^{-4}(1+z)$ yields no improvement in $\alpha_\mathrm{MG}$ precision.
• Found that shallow, narrower spectroscopic surveys are superior to deep, wide photometric surveys for achieving precise constraints on modified gravity parameters.
• Identified that accurate determination of cluster centers is essential in high signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) regimes, as mis-centering can introduce biases mimicking significant deviations from General Relativity (GR).

Limitations

The study focuses on specific observational uncertainties and theoretical modeling choices for galaxy clusters; the general applicability to other cosmological probes might differ.

Open Questions & Future Work

• modified-gravity-models-post-gw170817
• modified-gravity-cluster-potential-alteration
• explore-alternative-gravity-parameterizations
• full-survey-realism-systematics-modelling
• self-consistent-modified-gravity-halo-catalogues
• accurate-cluster-center-determination-strategies
• full-3d-jeans-equation-velocity-modelling
• propagating-mass-uncertainty-survey-specific-mocks

Datasets

• halo catalogue

Limitations

The study focuses on specific observational uncertainties and theoretical modeling choices for galaxy clusters; the general applicability to other cosmological probes might differ.

Links

• ArXiv Abstract
• PDF