Massive star clusters detected by JWST as natural birth places to form intermediate-mass black holes

Authors: Dominik R. G. Schleicher, Matías Liempi, Mirek Giersz, Marcelo C. Vergara, Francesco Flammini Dotti, Paulo Solar, Andrés Escala, Muhammad A. Latif, Bastián Reinoso, Abbas Askar, Raffaella Schneider, Roberto Capuzzo-Dolcetta, Jorge Saavedra-Bastidas, Fernando Cuevas Date: 2026-03-25 Paper ID: arxiv:2603.24550

Summary

This work investigates whether Young Massive Star Clusters (YMCs) detected by JWST act as birthplaces for intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs). The authors compare the population properties of these YMCs, particularly their mass-radius relation and short dynamical timescales, to theoretical expectations for runaway collision-based IMBH formation. They quantitatively estimate that approximately 16% of YMCs, those beyond the $1\sigma$ scatter in the mass-radius relation, are likely candidates to form IMBHs. Furthermore, clusters exceeding $\sim 6 \times 10^6 M_\odot$ are predicted to retain gas, accelerating central object growth through dynamical friction and Bondi accretion, while also considering a gas-dominated channel for direct high-mass black hole formation.

Key Contributions

• Established that a significant fraction of JWST-detected Young Massive Star Clusters (YMCs) are candidates for forming intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs) via runaway collision channels.
• Quantified the required cluster size ($\gtrsim 1\sigma$ scatter in the mass-radius relation) necessary for efficient IMBH formation via runaway collisions.
• Demonstrated that YMCs above $\sim 6 \times 10^6 M_\odot$ likely retain gas despite supernova feedback, facilitating rapid IMBH growth via gas friction and Bondi accretion.
• Investigated the alternative scenario where gas-dominated regimes in YMCs could lead to the direct formation of high-mass black holes via strong gravitational torques.

Limitations

The analysis relies on theoretical modeling of cluster evolution and comparisons with local/Milky Way clusters, and the JWST observations primarily provide lensing signatures, requiring subsequent dynamical modeling. The specific observational confirmation of IMBH formation within these YMCs remains a future step.

Open Questions & Future Work

• stellar-bh-cluster-interaction-uncertainty
• collision-bh-formation-simulation-gap
• stellar-collision-imf-uncertainty
• massive-cluster-gas-dynamics-refinement
• gas-vs-collision-formation-distinction

Key Concepts

• Intermediate-Mass Black Hole Formation: Formation of black holes with masses between stellar-mass black holes and supermassive black holes, often hypothesized to occur in dense star clusters.

Limitations

The analysis relies on theoretical modeling of cluster evolution and comparisons with local/Milky Way clusters, and the JWST observations primarily provide lensing signatures, requiring subsequent dynamical modeling. The specific observational confirmation of IMBH formation within these YMCs remains a future step.

Links

• ArXiv Abstract
• PDF